A Utah solution for water banking
In 2017 a diverse stakeholder group of over 70 people including representatives from agriculture, public water suppliers, conservation groups and other interests began to meet to develop a Utah water banking concept. The stakeholder group spent thousands of hours discussing marketing concepts, studying existing activities in the various basins in Utah, reviewing water banking programs in other western states and receiving public feedback.
To support these efforts, in 2019, SJR 1 was passed endorsing the continued study of water banking and drafting of a water banking bill, authorizing a one-time $400,000 appropriation, and supporting seeking $400,000 in funding from the Bureau of Reclamation WaterSMART Water Marketing Grant program. The money funded a project team to oversee a multi-year effort to pilot the Water Banking Act and develop statewide water marketing strategies.
Utah Water Banking Act: temporary, voluntary and local
In 2020, with near unanimous support, the Utah Legislature passed the Utah Water Banking Act (SB 26) – now Utah Code 73-31. The Water Banking Act focused on three key principles: temporary, voluntary and local transfers of water. It works by empowering local water users to design a water transaction suited to local needs.
The act recognizes two forms of leasing arrangements that can qualify to be approved as a Utah Water Bank.
- Contract Water Bank: Utah Code 73-31-301 et seq.
Water leasing contracts are voluntary arrangements that outline the terms and conditions for the use of water between a discrete set of parties. Many water users in Utah already use contracts to lease water. Water leasing contracts that meet the criteria of the act are eligible to apply to be a contract water bank. To prevent private speculation of water, the applicant for a contract water bank must be a non-federal public entity. - Statutory Water Bank: Utah Code 73-31-201 et seq.
A statutory water bank is a legal entity organized for the purpose of administering and facilitating water leasing between multiple parties in a defined area. Statutory water banks are modeled after private irrigation companies and run on private governance documents such as articles, bylaws or other organizational documents. The applicant for a statutory water bank must be the owner of a perfected water right.
Once an application is approved by the Board of Water Resources, water banks are extended certain benefits and protections. In particular, water rights deposited into a water bank are exempt from forfeiture; water rights can be leased for environmental purposes; and water banks are subject to a streamlined change application proceeding that provides participants greater flexibility.
Frequently asked questions
What is the Water Banking Act?
The Water Banking Act (Utah Code 73-31) promotes temporary, voluntary and locally directed leasing arrangements for the use of water rights. Leasing arrangements retain local ownership of water rights, create income and provide expanded water access.
The act provides water users ultimate flexibility to design a leasing arrangement that meets local conditions. Local water users can determine the size and scale of a bank’s service area, which water rights participate, lease prices, lease terms, conditions for leasing, distribution of proceeds, etc..
What are the benefits of water banking?
- Streamlined administrative process: Once water rights are approved to be deposited in a water bank, no additional change applications or state approvals are needed to move water to a new use within the approved service area. This is intended to facilitate quicker and cheaper movement of water on a temporary basis.
- Forfeiture: Water rights approved to be deposited in a water bank are exempt from beneficial use requirements and protected from forfeiture.
- Environmental/Instream-Flows: Banked water can be leased for any purpose authorized by the act, including instream flows.
- Condemnation Protections: Banked water is shielded from any condemnation procedures while in the bank and for a period of time afterwards.
Isn't water banking already being done in Utah?
Yes, though not termed “water banking.” There are already a few informal efforts around Utah that are similar to water banking. The legislation would not affect those efforts. It would, however, create a 10-year pilot program that would establish a statutory framework. The framework would give water right holders the option of creating and operating their own water banks. The banks would be subject to public notice and comment, oversight from the Board of Water Resources and coordination with the State Engineer.
How would a water right holder be protected from abandonment and forfeiture when putting water into a bank?
Water right holders would retain ownership of their water rights. The rights would revert to their prior “heretofore” use when withdrawn from the bank without the need for a change application. Water rights deposited within a bank would also not be subject to abandonment and forfeiture for the period of time the State Engineer authorizes them to be used within a bank.
How would the banks be locally driven?
The decision to create, or participate in, a water bank would be entirely voluntary and would be made at the local level. The banks would be locally managed. Only a record holder of a perfected water right may request approval for a statutory water bank and designate the service area of a water bank. No banks would be managed at the state level.
What types of banks could be formed?
- Contract:
- Many water users already have leases arranged by contract.
- A contract water bank would apply in those cases or where a review of local conditions shows the desired water market activity is best managed through a contract.
- A contract water bank seeks approval to utilize a specific water transfer contract consistent with the terms of a water bank and with the flexibility provided by the act.
- A contract water bank application asks water users to submit general information about the contract and a copy of the contract.
- The applicant for a contract water bank must be a non-federal public entity to prevent private water speculation: other parties to the contract do not need to be public entities.
- Statutory:
- A statutory bank is a legal entity organized for the purpose of administering leasing activity between parties in a defined area.
- Statutory water banks are modeled after private irrigation companies and run on private governance documents such as articles, bylaws, and policy documents.
- A statutory water bank seeks approval to develop new and unspecified water lease agreements under a locally managed water bank.
- A statutory water bank application requires that the applicant demonstrate they have addressed a number issues needed for prudent management and leasing of water.
- The applicant of a statutory bank must be the owner of a perfected water right and participation is open to all interested water users.
Would the change application process change?
No. Water right holders seeking to move a water right into a bank would go through the same change application process that applies to all water rights. This means the State Engineer would review all applications that seek to place a water right into a bank to ensure that they do not impair other rights. It also means that the existing limitations on out-of-basin transfers would apply.
After the State Engineer approves a right for use within a bank, the right could be used for a specified period of time within the bank’s service area for other uses without the need for another change application. This, of course, would be subject to any limitations imposed by the State Engineer.
How will we know if water banking is working?
As a pilot program, every bank would submit an annual report to the Board of Water Resources. At the end of the pilot program, the board would report on the effectiveness of the water banking program to the Legislature. The Legislature would then determine whether to continue the program, modify it, or allow it to terminate.
Because this program is intended to be a pilot program, the draft legislation is intended to keep it as simple as possible to limit the potential for unintended consequences and to make it easier to study the effectiveness of the program.
What do I need to pursue water banking in my area?
Water banking is one kind of water marketing tool. Water marketing strategies resources, such as the Foundational Questions Document, will help guide local water users through the key water marketing milestones needed to understand and assess water marketing potential in the area. The Water Marketing Methods and Water Marketing Transaction Types documents will help water users understand how best to structure a water transaction that fits their local needs. If creating a water bank under the Water Banking Act seems like the best fit, the application resources give further guidance on how to create and apply to be a Utah Water Bank.
More information on Utah water marketing can be found from our Water Marketing main page.
If you have questions or need further information, please email WaterMarketing@utah.gov.